Is Canada’s high-speed rail project dead? My glimmer of hope for better train service has faded away in recent months as the proposed Alto high-speed rail project faces fierce opposition.
Yet we need transportation alternatives beyond flying and driving. This was driven home on Friday when the ground stop at U.S. airports caused chaos across North America. Watching the news reports made me wonder if North Americans will ever embrace rail transportation in markets where it makes sense.
Train envy
I’m always amazed at the excellent train service in England and other European countries. Our train service in Canada is pitiful. When I travel to Toronto from Kitchener, I usually choose the GO Train over driving. The 108 kilometre journey takes just under two hours. We have no train service to Toronto on weekends. Evening service is sparse, making it impractical to take the train to Toronto for an evening event.
By comparison, when I visited England in 2023, my train journey from York to London took about the same amount of time as that train from Kitchener to Toronto. But the distance travelled is 323 kilometres. Three times the distance in the same amount of time!
Although high speed rail is not available on all routes in England, most small towns and cities have a train station connecting them with larger centres, making it easy to travel across the country. In Canada, most small- to mid-size towns have no rail service and service is infrequent and unreliable on routes that remain.

Is high-speed rail feasible in Canada?
Long distances combined with a small population mean high-speed rail travel doesn’t make sense in many parts of Canada. However, half of Canada’s population lives in the Windsor to Quebec City corridor. That 1,100 kilometre corridor includes the cities of Windsor, London, Kitchener-Waterloo, Toronto, Kingston, Montreal and Quebec City. Improved train service should be a no-brainer along this route.
In recent years, there has been hope. In 2023, Transport Canada issued a Request for Proposal for a high speed, high frequency rail project between Toronto and Quebec City. This could replace short haul flights between Toronto, Montreal, Ottawa and Quebec City. It seemed the Alto High Speed Rail project might see the light of day.
At the time, I expressed skepticism this would be built in my lifetime. It turns out I was right.
The argument against high-speed rail
As with any costly large scale project, there have been protests. Most of the arguments against Alto relate to the $60 to $90 billion cost, loss of farmland, and lack of service to some of the communities along the route.
Opponents suggest simply upgrading existing rail service instead. Alto maintains it needs brand new infrastructure to compete with airlines on travel time. Sharing tracks with freight trains makes it difficult to improve existing service. In 2021, Via Rail proposed upgrading to a faster, electrified high-frequency rail service running on dedicated tracks at an estimated cost of $12 billion.
The current federal government appears committed to Alto. The recent federal budget proposed legislation to accelerate the construction of the project. Opposition parties are not on board, however, so a change in federal government could drive the final nail in the coffin.
The Ontario and Quebec provincial governments are a different story altogether. Quebec’s recently elected Parti Québecois government opposes the project. Ontario Premier Doug Ford has made it very clear he’d rather spend billions on highways and tunnels to keep people in their cars than invest in public transit.
Canada’s high-speed rail project is clearly a political hot potato.
Let’s keep in touch! Join my mailing list and I’ll email you when I add a new post.
We need bold action
If we ever hope to reduce our dependence on fossil fuels, we need to offer viable alternatives to flying and driving. Investing in faster, more reliable train service in the Windsor to Quebec City corridor makes so much sense from an economic and environmental point of view.
Yet I’m still skeptical that we’ll see high-speed or high-frequency rail service in Canada in my lifetime.
For now, I will continue to hope the Ontario government delivers on their promise of two-way, all-day GO Train service between Kitchener and Toronto. At least then I would never need to drive to Toronto again!
How is the public transit service where you live? Drop me a comment below and let me know.
Discover more from Boomer Eco Crusader
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
